No. The second cheapest wine on the menu is not a bad deal, and the old tip that restaurants park their worst value in that slot does not hold up. A bottle's position in the price column tells you almost nothing. What the bottle is tells you almost everything.
The tip is so widespread that it is worth taking apart properly, because it makes people nervous about a perfectly good order and nudges them toward bottles they like less. Here is where it came from, what restaurant pricing really looks like, and a simpler rule to use instead.
where the second cheapest wine tip came from
The story goes like this. Nobody wants to look cheap in front of a date or a client, so people skip the cheapest bottle and point at the one just above it. Restaurants know this, so they put the wine with the biggest markup (the gap between what they paid for the bottle and what you pay) in that exact spot. You think you are being sensible. They think you are predictable.
It is a satisfying story because it flatters you for seeing through it. It has been repeated in newspaper columns, at dinner parties and on wine forums for decades, and once you have heard it, it is hard to look at a wine list without feeling that the second line is a trick.
The trouble is that nobody can point to the restaurant that actually does this. Wine buyers and sommeliers (the person in charge of a restaurant's wine) tend to say the opposite when asked. The second cheapest bottle is the one they expect to sell by the case, so it is usually a wine they are happy to stand behind. Putting a dud there would mean fielding complaints all night.
what the pricing actually looks like
Restaurant markups are real and they are large, but they do not follow the shape the tip assumes. Most places charge roughly two to three times the shop price for a bottle, sometimes more, and the multiple shifts up and down the list in ways that vary from one restaurant to the next. Our post on why restaurant wine costs so much walks through the whole pricing picture.
On the specific question of the second cheapest slot, the best evidence points the other way. A widely reported study by economists who went through several hundred London restaurant wine lists found no sign of a second cheapest trap. The percentage markup on the second cheapest bottle was lower than on the third, fourth and fifth cheapest. It was one city in one year, and markups varied a lot between venues and even within a single list, so treat it as a strong hint rather than a law. But it is a strong hint, and it matches what people in the trade say.
The pattern many restaurants do follow is simpler and less sneaky. The cheapest bottles often carry a bigger multiple, because they can and still look cheap on the page. Expensive bottles usually carry a smaller multiple, because a straight triple would produce a number that frightens the whole table. Where the multiple peaks in between differs from place to place. None of it singles out line two.
why the slot still feels risky, and why it is not
Part of the worry is social. Ordering near the bottom of the list feels like admitting something, and the second cheapest feels like a compromise everyone can see through. Nobody at the table is thinking that. Servers see the whole range of orders every night, and a thoughtful choice near your budget reads as confidence, not thrift.
The other part is that cheap wine can be worse wine. That is sometimes true, but it has nothing to do with the slot. A restaurant that cares about its list puts something good at every price, including the bottom. A restaurant that does not care has weak bottles scattered all over the page, and the second cheapest is no more likely to be one of them than the fifth cheapest.
If the second cheapest bottle is a grape you like, from a region you recognize, with a producer or a village named on the list, it is as safe an order as anything on the page. If it is a vague line with no detail ("red blend, California"), be a little more careful, exactly as you would with any other vague line.
a better rule for the price column
Instead of avoiding a slot, use the price column for the one thing it is good at: showing you where you are comfortable. Then choose by the wine.
- Decide your number before you open the list, per bottle or per glass depending on how the table is drinking. Knowing it in advance stops the price column from steering you.
- Read across the row, not down the column. Grape, region, producer, year. If two of those four mean something to you, the bottle is a reasonable bet whatever it costs.
- Look for detail. A list that names the producer and the village for an inexpensive bottle is telling you that someone chose it on purpose.
- Favor regions and grapes that are not famous. Southern France, Portugal, Spain beyond Rioja, southern Italy, Chile and South Africa tend to be priced for what is in the glass rather than for the name on the label.
- Ask one question. "I am thinking about this one. Is it drinking well?" Servers answer that all day, and the ones who taste the list will steer you to the better value if you have missed it.
If you want to get faster at the reading part, our guide to reading a restaurant wine list in about a minute shows what to look at first.
how to order it without a second thought
When you have found the bottle, order it plainly. Point at it or say the name, and do not apologize for the price. "We will have the Côtes du Rhône" lands exactly the same whether it is the second line or the twentieth.
If you would rather hand the decision to the server, show them your budget by pointing at a price on the list and say what you like in plain words: "something around this, dry and not too heavy." That is a better conversation than any slot-based trick, and it works on every list in every restaurant. Green Glass has a Show Somm screen for exactly this moment: one view of your taste profile, budget first, with plain "pour me" and "avoid" lines you can hand across the table instead of improvising. For the rest of the exchange, from the first pour to sending back a bad bottle, our guide to ordering wine at a restaurant covers it step by step.
The short version: the second cheapest wine on the menu is a normal bottle at a normal price. Judge it like any other line. Spend what you planned to spend, choose the wine you recognize, and let the slot myth go.
questions people ask
Is the second cheapest wine on the menu the worst value?
No. There is no reliable evidence that restaurants put their biggest markup on the second cheapest bottle, and a large study of London wine lists found its markup was lower than on the next few bottles up the list. Judge it on the grape and region like any other wine.
Which bottle on a wine list usually has the highest markup?
It varies by restaurant. Many places put the largest multiple on the cheapest bottles because they still look inexpensive on the page, while expensive bottles usually carry a smaller multiple. No single slot is a reliable trap.
Is it rude to order the cheapest wine on the menu?
No. Servers see every kind of order every night. If the cheapest bottle is a grape or region you like, order it with a straight face.
How do I pick a good value wine at a restaurant?
Decide your budget first, then read across the line: grape, region, producer. Favor less famous regions, look for bottles the list describes in detail, and ask the server what is drinking well near your price.
Should I tell the server my budget?
Yes. The easy way is to point at a price on the list and say "something around here." It keeps the number private from the table and gets you a better recommendation.



