back to the blog

What is traditional method sparkling wine? A plain guide

What "traditional method" means on a sparkling wine label, how the bubbles get into the bottle, which wines use it, and when it is worth the extra money.

wine culture
Red wine bottles and vinyl records on a patterned rug

Traditional method sparkling wine is wine that got its bubbles from a second fermentation inside the same bottle you buy, then rested on its spent yeast for months or years before being cleaned up and corked. Champagne is the famous example, and the phrase on a label usually promises finer, longer-lasting bubbles and a toasty, bready flavor that quicker methods cannot copy.

That is the whole idea. The rest of this post walks through what actually happens inside the bottle, how it differs from Prosecco-style fizz, which wines are made this way, and when the extra cost buys you something you can taste.

same method, five different names on the label

Producers around the world use this process, but the wording changes with the country. These all mean the same thing:

  • Traditional method or méthode traditionnelle (France and most of Europe outside Champagne)
  • Méthode champenoise (the old name; in Europe it is now reserved for Champagne, but some US bottles still use it)
  • Metodo classico (Italy)
  • Cap Classique or Méthode Cap Classique (South Africa)
  • Fermented in this bottle (a US label phrase that signals the same process)

If you see none of these, the wine was probably made in a tank or simply carbonated. Neither is a crime, but it tells you what to expect in the glass.

bubbles born inside the bottle

Every sparkling wine starts as a still, bone-dry base wine, usually low in alcohol and sharp with acid. The traditional method takes that base wine, adds a small dose of sugar and yeast, and seals it in a bottle with a crown cap (the same cap you see on a beer bottle).

The yeast eats the sugar and makes a little more alcohol plus carbon dioxide. With the cap on, the gas has nowhere to go, so it dissolves into the wine. That is the second fermentation, and it is where the bubbles come from. Because the gas builds slowly and under pressure in a small space, the bubbles end up tiny and tightly packed, and they keep streaming long after the pour.

the dead yeast that makes it taste like toast

Once the yeast has finished its job it dies and sinks, forming a cloudy layer called lees (lees are dead yeast cells, nothing more mysterious than that). Instead of removing them, the producer leaves the wine sitting on them, often for years.

As the yeast cells break down they release compounds that give the wine its signature flavors: fresh bread, brioche, toast, biscuit, sometimes a nutty or creamy note. The longer the wine sits on lees, the stronger these flavors get and the softer the texture becomes. Champagne law requires at least 15 months in the bottle for a non-vintage wine and three years for a vintage one, and many producers go well beyond that. If you want to pick these notes out yourself, our simple guide to tasting wine covers how to smell for them.

riddling and disgorging: getting the gunk out

At this point you have a great wine with a layer of dead yeast in it, and nobody wants to pour that. Two steps fix it.

Riddling means tilting and turning the bottle a little at a time, over days or weeks, until it is nearly upside down and all the sediment has slid into the neck. It used to be done by hand in wooden racks; most of it is now done by machines that rotate whole crates of bottles.

Disgorging is the dramatic part. The neck of the bottle is dipped in a freezing solution so the sediment turns into a small ice plug. The cap comes off, the pressure inside fires the plug out, and the wine behind it stays clear. The producer tops up the small loss with a splash of wine, usually with a little sugar in it, which sets the final sweetness level. That is why labels say Brut (dry), Extra Brut (drier) or, confusingly, Extra Dry (a touch sweeter than Brut). Then in goes the cork.

the two shortcuts: tank method and plain carbonation

The tank method, also called the Charmat method, does the second fermentation in a big sealed steel tank instead of in individual bottles. The wine is then filtered and bottled under pressure. It is faster, cheaper and keeps the wine tasting fresh and fruity, because there is little or no time on lees. Prosecco is made this way, and so are most Lambrusco and Asti. The bubbles are a little bigger and softer and fade sooner in the glass. For a sunny patio or a spritz, that is often exactly what you want.

Plain carbonation is the soda approach: carbon dioxide is pumped into a finished still wine. It is the cheapest route, and the bubbles are big, loud and gone quickly. You will mostly find it in the lowest-priced fizz and in some canned wine.

So the ladder, from most effort to least, runs: traditional method, tank method, carbonation. Flavor tends to go from toasty and layered at the top to simple and fruity at the bottom.

who makes wine this way

The traditional method is not just for Champagne. These categories all use it, and most of them cost a good deal less:

  • Champagne from France, the original and usually the priciest
  • Crémant from other French regions (Alsace, Loire, Burgundy, Limoux and more)
  • Cava from Spain, often the best value on the shelf
  • Franciacorta and Trento from northern Italy
  • Cap Classique from South Africa
  • English sparkling wine, a newer category with a growing reputation
  • Many US sparkling wines, especially from California, Oregon and New Mexico, some made by Champagne houses with American outposts

Napa and the cool Carneros area are a good example: the well-known sparkling wines there are made the traditional way.

what it costs and when it is worth paying for

Prices vary by store and state, but as a rough guide, tank-method Prosecco usually sits around $10 to $18. Traditional method starts not far above that: Cava is often $12 to $20, Crémant and Cap Classique roughly $18 to $30, and most Champagne begins around $40 and climbs fast.

It is worth the step up when:

  • The bubbles are the point of the evening and you want them to last through the toast
  • You are pairing with food, especially anything fried, salty or creamy, where the toasty flavor and sharp acid earn their keep
  • You like bready, nutty, rich flavors more than straight-up fruit

Skip it and buy tank method when you are making mimosas or spritzes, serving a big crowd that will not notice, or you simply prefer light, peachy, easy fizz. If you are not sure which camp you fall into, the Green Glass taste quiz takes a minute and will tell you. And if you are staring at a restaurant list where a glass of "Brut" is listed with no region, our guide to ordering wine at a restaurant has a few questions that will sort out what you are getting.

questions people ask

Is traditional method the same as Champagne?

No. Champagne is one region in France that uses the traditional method; Cava, Crémant, Franciacorta, Cap Classique and many US wines use the same process without the Champagne name or price.

Why does traditional method sparkling wine taste like bread?

After the second fermentation the dead yeast cells (the lees) stay in the bottle for months or years and slowly break down, releasing flavors of toast, brioche and biscuit into the wine.

Is Prosecco a traditional method wine?

No. Prosecco is made by the tank method, where the second fermentation happens in a large pressurized tank, which keeps it fresh and fruity with softer bubbles.

Does "méthode champenoise" mean it is Champagne?

Not necessarily. It is simply the old name for the traditional method, and some US producers still print it on bottles made far from Champagne.

Is traditional method sparkling wine always better?

It is usually more complex and the bubbles last longer, but "better" depends on the moment. For cocktails, spritzes or a light, fruity glass, a good tank-method wine can be the smarter buy.

read similar blogs

Press Space to play